Several people have expressed a preference that when a pane divider is dragged, nothing else changes. So, if we have panes A,B,C,D,E, and divider A|B is dragged to the right, then A gets wider, B gets narrower, and C, D, and E do not move or change.
But suppose you want A wider but everything else to stay the same width, then you have to first drag A|B, then B|C, then C|D, then D|E. Four drags.
My preference is that when A|B is dragged right, A gets wider and everything else moves over. Much simpler for my use case.
For your use case, IIUC, you want everything else to stay visible, not scroll to the right. Ok, then with my proposal, you just need to drag A|B to the right, then drag B|C to the left. Two drags.
So my proposal takes 1 drag for my use case and 2 drags for your use case.
Your proposal takes 1 drag for your use case and multiple drags (depending on number of panes) for my use case.
What happens when B/C gets dragged right or left? Only B is effected? The focus is always on the pane to the left?
Assuming that’s the case I like this better. All you have to think about is what you’re doing to one pane, left to narrow or right to widen. Everything else stays the same.
There is one edge case with the above simple rule – what happens when dragging B/C to the left would move the right edge of the right-most pane (E in my example) into the body of the window? A strict application of the rule, keeping pane E at its original width, would leave whitespace to the right of pane E. In contrast, in the current implementation, the right edge of that pane stays at the right edge of the window, so the pane gets wider. I’m fine with either way.
I’d like to add why I think the side scrolling for panes is really annoying:
Let’s say I open a pane, so I have a split view. 50% and 50%. No side scrolling. Then, for a while, I need to focus more on the pane on the right, so I drag the pane divider more to the left (for having a bigger pane on the right). After, I drag the divider back to its original position. But now the whole pane moves with it – I can’t drag it back to the original size/position, its behaving in a different, in my opinion not logical way. So I have to drag the right side of the right pane back into a new position as well (and it takes a moment to find the right amount to not still have some side scrolling). This is what’s annoying and frustrating.
I don’t think so. This (right here) is the thread where the WF team asked for feedback on this precise question, which is what Adrian did. The thread that you reference is for collecting multiple pane issues. Continuing this long discussion there would muddy that thread.
Agreed, this is an important use-case. What would you think of a command to resize all panes to equal widths? That would seem to address your issue and also several others.
First off – I love the panes feature and it is part of my daily workflow now.
I have a dashboard arrangement that shows (from left to right)
Inbox
Straggler tasks
Projects
Today (calendar node)
I use a workflowy URL link as my way of “restoring” this pane view, and then use “close panes” hotkey to reduce it back down to a single pane view as needed.
I would love if you could arrange panes and then save the layout (including column widths) and be able to launch/restore the layout from the left-navigation panel. The URL method I use does not save column widths, so I have to re-size each time I launch my “dashboard.”
Otherwise, the resizing behavior of dragging the dividers of the panes seems logical and intuitive to me as it is today.